Partners Plumbing Co.
Call Now

Common Toilet Problems: Running, Weak Flush, Leaks—What You Can Fix vs. When to Call a Plumber

user

•
Categories:Blog

A malfunctioning toilet can waste water, damage your bathroom floor, and disrupt daily routines. While some toilet issues are simple fixes, others require professional expertise to prevent water damage and ensure proper function.

Partners Plumbing Co. has resolved thousands of toilet problems across Kane County. We’ll help you understand which issues you can safely handle yourself and when it’s time to call a licensed plumber.

Most Common Toilet Problems (And Their Causes)

1. Running Toilet: The Constant Water Sound

What’s happening: Water continuously flows from the tank into the bowl after flushing.

Cause: Usually a worn flapper valve inside the tank that fails to seal properly.

DIY Fix (Often Successful):

  • Lift the tank lid carefully
  • Check if the flapper seals tightly against the drain opening
  • If worn or cracked, you can purchase a replacement flapper kit at any hardware store ($10–$20)
  • Follow kit instructions for installation

When to call a professional: If replacing the flapper doesn’t solve it, the issue may involve the flush valve itself (requires tank removal).

Water waste impact: A running toilet can waste 200 gallons per day, significantly increasing your water bill.

2. Weak or Incomplete Flush

What’s happening: Toilet doesn’t have enough force to clear waste, requiring multiple flushes.

Common Causes:

  • Clogged or partially blocked drain
  • Mineral buildup reducing water flow into bowl
  • Flapper opening only partially
  • Insufficient water level in tank

DIY Diagnostics:

  • Check water level inside tank—should be about 1 inch below overflow tube
  • Adjust fill valve if level is too low
  • Plunge the bowl several times to clear minor clogs
  • Clean the small water inlet holes under the rim using a wire or allen wrench

Professional fixes:

  • Advanced clog removal if DIY plunging fails
  • Mineral descaling for hard water buildup
  • Complete toilet replacement if internal mechanisms are severely damaged

3. Toilet Leaks: Location Matters

Type A: Tank-to-Bowl Leak (Water Inside Tank)

Visible signs: Water slowly rises inside tank after flushing, then leaks into bowl.

Cause: Cracked tank (usually requires replacement) or faulty fill valve.

DIY Check:

  • Add food coloring to tank
  • Wait 30 minutes without flushing
  • If color appears in bowl, there’s a leak

Professional solution: Tank replacement or valve repair.

Type B: Leak at Toilet Base

Visible signs: Water pooling around base of toilet, water damage on floor below.

Cause: Worn wax ring seal (most common), cracked porcelain, or loose bolts.

Risks: Water damage to subfloor, mold growth, structural damage.

Professional fix required: Replacing wax ring requires removing toilet, which should only be done by licensed plumbers to avoid damage.

Type C: Leak from Supply Line Connection

Visible signs: Dripping or spraying water at connection where supply line enters toilet.

Cause: Loose nut, corrosion, or damaged supply line.

DIY Fix (Sometimes):

  • Tighten connection nut with adjustable wrench
  • If tightening doesn’t help, the supply line needs replacement

When to call: Persistent leaks or signs of corrosion indicate valve or line replacement is needed.

4. Clogs: From Simple to Serious

Minor Clog (DIY Fixable):

  • Single flush backs up but drains slowly
  • Use flange plunger 15–20 times
  • Success rate: 70–80% for simple blockages

Recurring Clogs (Professional Help Needed):

  • Same toilet clogs repeatedly despite plunging
  • Indicates deeper blockage in main line or pipe damage
  • Requires camera inspection and professional cleaning

Severe Blockage (Emergency Service):

  • Toilet backs up immediately, won’t drain at all
  • Water rises toward overflow
  • Multiple toilets or fixtures backing up
  • Call 630-715-8829 for emergency service

5. Phantom Flush: Random Filling Without Flushing

Cause: Fill valve slowly leaking into bowl, creating pressure that triggers periodic refilling.

DIY Check:

  • Add food coloring to tank
  • Watch if color slowly leaks into bowl
  • This confirms fill valve problem

Professional Fix: Fill valve replacement (usually $100–$250).

What You Can Safely Repair Yourself

✓ Replacing flapper valve (simple, inexpensive kit) ✓ Adjusting water level in tank ✓ Tightening supply line connections ✓ Plunging minor clogs ✓ Cleaning mineral deposits from rim holes

What Requires Professional Help

✗ Wax ring replacement (requires toilet removal) ✗ Persistent leaks at base ✗ Cracked tank or bowl ✗ Internal component damage requiring tank disassembly ✗ Recurring or severe clogs ✗ Supply line leaks or replacement ✗ Valve replacement in complex systems

Why DIY Toilet Repair Can Go Wrong

Risks include:

  • Cracking porcelain during removal or reinstallation
  • Improper wax ring installation causing ongoing leaks
  • Damaging internal components
  • Creating larger problems while fixing minor ones
  • Water damage to flooring and substructure

Local Toilet Issues in Kane County

Hard Water Problems: Kane County’s mineral-rich water creates buildup inside tank fill valves and flapper seats, causing frequent replacement needs.

Aging Systems: Homes in Geneva and St. Charles often have 20+ year old toilets with worn internal parts. Simple repairs become recurring problems.

Frequent Service Areas: We regularly service toilets in homes throughout South Elgin, Aurora, and Batavia with specialized knowledge of local plumbing code requirements.

Professional Toilet Services Available

Repair Services:

  • Running toilet diagnosis and repair
  • Fill valve and flapper replacement
  • Leak detection and sealing
  • Clog removal
  • Wax ring replacement
  • Water level adjustment

Replacement & Installation:

  • Modern water-efficient toilet installation
  • Comfort-height toilet upgrade
  • Pressure-assisted models
  • Eco-friendly options

Prevention Tips

  • Monthly inspection: Check for leaks or unusual sounds
  • Avoid harsh flushes: Don’t force foreign objects or excessive amounts of paper
  • Use appropriate paper: Standard toilet paper only—no wipes, feminine products, or paper towels
  • Annual maintenance: Professional inspection catches problems early
  • Address issues quickly: Small leaks become big problems

Case Study: When DIY Goes Wrong

A St. Charles homeowner attempted DIY wax ring replacement without proper tools. The misaligned toilet created an ongoing leak that damaged the subfloor before discovery. Professional replacement and subfloor repair cost $1,200—far more than the original $150 professional job would have cost.

When to Call Partners Plumbing Co.

Call immediately if:

  • Toilet leaks at base (water damage risk)
  • Persistent clogs despite plunging
  • Multiple toilets backing up (main line issue)
  • Sewage odors or unusual sounds

Schedule service soon for:

  • Running toilets that don’t stop
  • Weak or incomplete flushes
  • Slow water level rise
  • Phantom flushing

Conclusion: Know Your Limits

While homeowners can handle some simple toilet repairs, most issues benefit from professional diagnosis and repair. Calling a plumber early prevents water damage, extends toilet life, and ensures proper function.

Trust the experts at Partners Plumbing Co.:

Serving: Kane County, Geneva, St. Charles, South Elgin, and nearby communities

Related Services:

Partners Plumbing Co.—licensed, insured, and trusted by over 5,000 Kane County homeowners since 2009.